Author
|
Topic: How the rest of the world views the United States
|
|
|
Delightful Little Capuchin Monkey
VoivodFan
Member # 65
|
posted June 19, 2003 22:12
Just out of curiosity, when you make a blanket statement like 'typical American', is it based on the hundreds of thousands of individual US citizens you know? I would think it would have to be, otherwise I might assume that you were stereotyping. You know, like saying 'typical minority' out selling crack like they're shown doing on COPS and on the news. Or 'typical Canadian' with an inferiority complex, a slow wit and a penchant for flannel, hockey and punctuating every phrase with 'eh?' like from comedy sketches. Likewise, 'typical French' - the cowardly snobs. 'Typical Russians', the depressive Vodka-hounds and horribly ugly, fat and dowdy mole-faced women. 'Typical Brits' - bad teeth, "jolly good!", uptight, etc. - and the list goes on. When you say 'typical American', I actually do take offense. As for the self-loathing Americans on the board, I think back to an old Simpsons episode where Homer is watching the Def Comedy Jam and a black comic is talking about how "black folks drive all cool-like and white folks drive *like this* (putting an uptight affect in his voice)" and Homer laughs his ass off, saying "It's true! We're so LAME!" Do yourself a favor and please don't equate the actions of a government - whether good or bad - with the people it governs. And for crying out loud - don't assume that I have a Big Mac in one hand and the remote in the other switching between King of Queens and American Idol for my daily does of 'culture'. Guess I'm a little defensive.
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Delightful Little Capuchin Monkey
VoivodFan
Member # 65
|
posted June 20, 2003 09:10
quote: Originally posted by Noitall: I personally do not hold Americans responsible for their government's actions but millions of people worldwide do. One only needs to look to the Middle East to see examples of this sentiment.
But why should that be MY (or any other American citizen not connected with policy decisions) problem? Those millions of people who you say would hold me responsible for the actions of my government can fuck themselves. Seriously. And if they feel they're justified to hate me (or worse) to vent their frustrations or deem it justifiable (Jihad), then, again, they can fuck themselves. Should I apologize to the world for being American? Should I nod my head pensively and consider why I am deserving of hatred due to my ethnicity? I'm certainly not what you'd consider a "flag wavin', don't tread on me, Toby Keith-listenin'" guy (which is a stereotype - touche!), but I do appreciate the liberties that are afforded to me simply because I was born here. I'm not foolish enough to believe that US foreign policy doesn't piss off a considerable number of the peoples of the world, though. I'm just not going to be an apologist for something I don't contribute to. Another point I wanted to raise to X-D, and no disrespect is intended: which freedoms of yours have you lost due to the Patriot Act? Name one thing you've done all your life that you can't do today? What daily (or even occasional) activity of yours do you foresee losing, realistically? Again, not trying to be disrespectful, just wanted to follow-up on your previous post. And, Nia, I know you weren't saying that you hate Americans or anything. Just for the record. And re: being an apologist - if you don't make me apologize for Reagan's ignorance of the AIDS epidemic, I won't make you apologize for Celine Dion.
| IP: Logged
|
|
LyKcantropen
VoivodFan
Member # 162
|
posted June 20, 2003 09:15
It was me who mentioned the 'Patriot Act'. *spits*Not XD. Of course, you don't see the people this affects. They're all locked up in Guantanamo. But the most important thing is to see what it potentially paves the way for. And with Ashcroft in charge of justice/law? Congratulations, one more big terrorist attack and you're all fucked. Oh, and I'm British and hating it.
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
|
KnickerZohnonnof
VoivodFan
Member # 272
|
posted June 20, 2003 13:03
The USA is hated because it conducts foreign policy like it always knows best, when in the majority of cases it doesn't. I have spoken to many americans who despair at their country's actions and wish they'd not be so trigger happy.My main gripe with the US government and USA in general is that it has the highest resource use per head of population of any nation on the planet and almost seems to be proud of it. It emits over a quarter of all greenhouse gas emissions. It seems to view sustainability like it's for wierdos and decides instead to seek to plunder beautiful, undisturbed wildlife such as Alaska in it's relentless search for the energy to feed this machine. Not that other countries are beyond reproach on this one. It's just that the US appears to be easily the worst offender in my opinion and wants others to change their ways before it does anything about its own. Look at the Kyoto treaty; OK, Clinton signed up to something he had very little hope of implementing, but Bush simply tore the thing up, saying that third world countries did more harm and that, because of the forests in the US act as a 'carbon sink', they should be exempt from any climate protocols. How did he come to that conclusion?! Big business doesn't want a climate protocol in the US because it means they will have to put money back into the environment they are so happily raping for their profits. Again, most western economies aren't exempt from this criticism, it's just the US is again the worst offender. I guess it comes down to the double standards of it's domestic and foreign policy. It can do what it pleases on its own soil, just look at the CIA/FBI, but other countries who act in similar ways are villified. America's government needs to moderate it's inflammatory rhetoric otherwise it will become increasingly hated.
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
El Indio
VoivodFan
Member # 18
|
posted June 20, 2003 13:37
Believe it or not but Canada does play a very major role in world affairs. Heck, if Canada did not exist, China would invade Norway! How would you like to eat blue rice!?! It looks like this debate is turning into yet another one of them polarized ones whereas you have a huge group standing on each side of the fence and very little chance of a mutually acceptable resolution happening. We are talking about such conflicts as abortion, euthanasia, drug use, et al here. Also some of you people have touched on that so called "guilt by association" controversy which is a curse that has dogged mankind since our ancestors were first learning how to skin water buffalo. It really bothers me to see people talk about ALL americans or ALL iraqis or ALL fans of the Vancouver Canucks as being basically evil. Sure alot of the above are and a whole shit load are not. Also, someone mentioned about listeners of Heavy Metal as being unable to think even the most basic of thoughts. That person is RIGHT! But getting back to this debate, I look at the United States as being a modern day Rome. Heck, its not like everyone loved the Romans back in Augustus's day? I'm sure you would have come across alot of Carthagians, Greeks, Goths, and germanic tribesmen who would have jumped at the chance to sack Rome and drink lots of wine and rape a bunch of fine Roman maidens! That was where it was at for alot of people back then! Today alot of people have it in for the United States. It goes with the territory. If France or Belgium or Brazil was the most powerful country in the world then everyone would be on their cases! I for one wish Brazil was the leader because I would just love to sack the Copacobana!
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
X-D
VoivodFan
Member # 3
|
posted June 20, 2003 14:07
quote: Originally posted by Kane: Another point I wanted to raise to X-D, and no disrespect is intended: which freedoms of yours have you lost due to the Patriot Act? Name one thing you've done all your life that you can't do today? What daily (or even occasional) activity of yours do you foresee losing, realistically? Again, not trying to be disrespectful, just wanted to follow-up on your previous post.
Hey Kane, First of all, I do not consider myself a self-loathing American. In fact, despite my many disagreements with our govt's policies and a general lack of faith in many of my fellow citizens, I very much do appreciate the positive aspects and freedoms that I am able to take for granted because of my living here. At no time in my earlier post did I mention the Patriot Act. My comments were about my fellow citizens, many of whom I beleive would willingly hand over an unacceptable amount of their freedoms in turn for a 'safer', more police-state type of atmosphere in the name of 'security'. Attitudes like "if you aren't doing anything wrong, than you have nothing fear", do not sit well with me and sound not unlike something you would have heard in the Soviet Union some 20 years ago. I also believe that big-money corprate interests are possibly a larger threat to our freedoms than our government, which is supposed to be protecting us from such a thing, but instead is enabling it. First on the chopping block is our right to privacy! Hmmm.... you raise good points Kane and ya got me thinking man. But, like I said, it is often my fellow Americans that scare me more than the current administration. I do not have an avid interest in politics and therefore am (for the most part), not commenting on govt policies and practices. I do however, keenly observe the attitudes and behaviors of my friends, neighbors, and general population as I see it. All I'm stating is my opinions, based on those observations... nothing more.
| IP: Logged
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|